Ukraine Blog 16 - When You Sign A Deal With The Devil... There's A Price To Pay

Dear friends, family and colleagues,

One month has now passed since the Russians started their “adventure” in Ukraine. For the past two days it can be decisively said that the Ukrainians have gone on the offensive around Kyiv and Kherson. Russian troops are exhausted there and either suffering from frostbite around Kherson (ironically like the Wehrmacht who were sent to Russia in summer uniforms) and wet feet around Kyiv where the Ukrainians flooded the main area they hold.

It was already clear to me that especially around Kyiv the Russians gave up hope on proceeding with further offensives. Three days ago footage emerged that the Russians where moving their equipment in defensive earth berms.

(1) Marina Medvin 🇺🇸 on Twitter: "The Kremlin's forces appear to be digging in a strong defensive position around Kyiv as satellite imagery released on Friday pictured what appear to be Russian mines planted northwest of the capital. https://t.co/k2OCzP9kaq" / Twitter

This might have worked in conventional warfare thirty years ago, but against the very skilled Ukrainian artillery and Bayraktar drones, this is absolutely suicide. When you are in the position where the Russians are right now in the north-west of Kyiv, you need to stay mobile and continuously change your position to stay alive. I would like to emphasize that Russian troops are likely not encircled in the north-west of Kyiv as Western media reports, but their supply lines do have serious problems. @Western media: when an army approaches a city, it doesn’t mean that it’s immediately encircled. This is a circle ○. This is not a circle Ↄ! So Kyiv, Kharkiv, Bucha and Hostomel =  Ↄ, Mariopol = ○

On the East of Kyiv, the Ukrainians managed to beat back the Russians quite far of the city. Below video is from Lukyanovka, around 30 kilometers east of Brovary, which till now has been the main Russian pressure point East of Kyiv. It’s not clear Brovary itself, has also been cleared, but at the very least the Russian supply lines are under great threat.  

(1) Michael A. Horowitz on Twitter: "🚩The Ukrainian army reportedly recaptured Lukyanovka, east of Kyiv, destroying three tanks and 9 Infantry Fighting vehicles in the process. This is an important counter-offensive, as Lukyanovka is on the Russian supply line to Velyka Dymerka, near Brovary. https://t.co/gFPGF4EnkK" / Twitter

The Russians seem to have lost the initiative everywhere in Ukraine, except around the Donbass and most notably Mariupol. All their efforts seem to be focusing on capturing Mariupol as soon as possible. They go all in on this front and I think they will eventually capture the city. Although that will free up resources for deployments to other fronts, the Russian (and Ukrainian) manpower losses have been devastating. For the Ukrainians besides the souls lost, it’s less of a problem. As long as there’s resistance in Mariupol, it means that the rest of Ukraine can breathe. Therefore, I don’t see the Ukrainian resistance in Mariupol as a lost cause.

I get a lot of questions whether the Russian generals don’t feel ashamed to turn a city into rubble and deport its civilians. Short answer: No! The Russian generals are now in absolute overdrive suck up mode to boss in the Kremlin. The commander who gets Mariupol will undoubtedly receives the “Hero of the Russian Federation” reward. Too bad Putin will immediately give him another reward: take the next city: Either Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia or Dnipro. Good luck with that. As always when aligning with Putin: There’s a price to pay (more on that later)

Are the Russians capable of creating new colossal fuckups on the Southern Eastern front every day? Oh yes, they can! Yesterday, they extended their level of incompetence to the navy. They had the brilliant idea to supply the troops in Berdiansk via three of their Landing Ship – Tank (LST’s) and show on television the disembarkment of equipment. Of course the Ukrainians were watching as well.

(1) Rob Lee on Twitter: "Video of the Black Sea Fleet’s Orsk Project 1171 large landing ship offloading equipment in Berdyansk. https://t.co/qPAM5brcLC https://t.co/lKaywXLK0B" / Twitter

Two days later, this was the result of an Ukrainian attack (likely Bayraktar). Please enjoy, this is 10 minutes of HD footage of Russian incompetence. One of their LST’s completely destroyed and two others fleeing to the sea while on fire.

БЕРДЯНСК: взрывы и пожар в порту 24 марта 2022 года - YouTube

Many of my fellow OSINT analysts dismissed the importance of the hit as “minor.” However, I can’t stress how important this strike is for the following reasons

1.       Russia obviously has great difficulties performing even a limited amphibious operation. In order to succeed they are absolutely dependent on specifically this type of ship of which the Russian navy has only 21, nine (now eight) of which are deployed in the Black Sea. It means that when they lose just one ship, their capabilities suffer a great setback.

2.       Russian naval infantry absolutely was not eager to go on an amphibious adventure on the shores of Odessa. The sinking of one of their main assets won’t make their appetite bigger and will for sure cause a further drop in morale.

I absolutely can’t understand this incredible level of incompetence. Why not supply the troops via commercial cargo ships? The Russians have plenty of them. I suspect they wanted to shoot some very cheap propaganda clips. The only good action was to send the other two Ropucha class LST’s to the sea while burning. That for sure saved them. Later satellite footage showed they indeed managed to put out the fires.

In the West, NATO has absolutely waken up and has performed some very important and necessary force postures during the past couple of days.

1.       The US military deployed its very advanced Stryker brigade right to the Belarussian border. This is absolutely necessary to deter Russia from starting any offensive to take the Suwalki gap between Belarus and Kaliningrad. Russian state propaganda (usually a good indicator of what the Kremlin’s plans are) touted ideas during the past couple of days to take on Poland and Lithuania. The deployment of the Stryker brigade is essential in posing an effective deterrence.

(1) OSINTdefender on Twitter: "An Armored Stryker Convoy from what is presumed to be the U.S Army National Guard's 81st Stryker Brigade Combat Team currently deployed to Poland was spotted earlier today near the Bobrowniki - Bierestowica Border Crossing between Poland and Belarus. https://t.co/13BQuf3QYG" / Twitter

2.       The French deployed three of their Strategic Ballistic Nuclear Submarines (SSBN’s) at once. Normally there’s just one on patrol at any given time. The last time more than one was on patrol was during the 1980’s. Again: this deployment is very important to show the Russians that NATO means business. Like I said before: we should show strength, not weakness to the Russians.

(1) Michael Shurkin on Twitter: "A good thread on the normal readiness posture of France's SSBNs (in French), highlighting how unusual it is that currently 3/4 of the current SSBN fleet is at sea." / Twitter

And this is part of what will be a more realistic “new normal.” For the foreseeable future we will be in the situation that will have 100.000 battle ready NATO troops on the Eastern flank, nuclear assets on constant alert and that NATO members will be spending a lot of money on re-armament.

The Russians on the other hand seem to tend more and more towards mobilization of their reserve troops and possibly the population. It becomes clear right now that Russia’s allies, which Russia saved from disintegration during the past ten years are not eager to return Putin’s favor. Both Lukashenko and Assad seem to step back from sending their forces to the Ukrainian meatgrinder. And this shows the true nature of classic dictators: they are all opportunistic in nature and they come to realize that when they signed a deal with Putin, they sold their souls to the devil. For Putin it has always been: “I will save you, but there will be a price to pay in the future.” Now that Putin comes to collect, his friends don’t want to join in. Let’s have a look at the Syrians that might after all still be send in. In case they go, they will likely make things worse for the Russians on the battlefield.

1.       Syrians in Ukraine will fight on completely unknown terrain against and army and population they are absolutely not familiar with. Already Russians who know the cold are suffering from frostbite. I can’t imagine how that will go for the Syrians.

2.       Only some Syrian officers speak a little bit of Russian. All the troops on the battlefield only speak Arab. The Russians already have enormous problems sending orders in Russian to their own troops. When they mix the Syrians in, they will likely maneuver like headless chickens in the Russian lines causing more damage than good.

3.       Arab armies can for sure crush an insurgency, but they have a notoriously bad track record against well motivated and equipped conventional armies like the Israelis and the Americans. On unfamiliar terrain against the fanatically defending Ukrainians they wouldn’t stand a chance.

4.       The Syrian rebels smell blood. Most notably Suhail Muhammad Hamoud , a.k.a. “Abu TOW” already indicated very early on in the conflict that he’s willing to go to Ukraine to kill as many Russians as possible. Abu TOW, get’s his nickname from his experience with Saudi-supplied American BGM-71 TOW anti-tank missiles on the Syrian battlefield. Abu TOW is the most experienced guided anti-tank missile operator in the world, with over 140 confirmed kills.

Meet Abu TOW!

أبو التاو مقاتل متخصص بتدمير دبابات نظام الأسد - YouTube

I think Assad really doesn’t have appetite in sending his forces to far away Ukraine, but in case it would happen, we will see the Syrian civil war being played out on an European battlefield. Just when you think it can’t get more crazier…

Let this be a lesson for everyone: weak appeasement towards dictators or making deals with dictators means you’re signing a deal with the devil and your signature will be in blood. The deal may seem really good: there will always be a price to pay. I will close with a quote from the man that created many famous quotes: Winston Churchill

“An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile-hoping it will eat him last.”

Best regards and "Slava Ukraini!"

Niels

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ukraine Blog 65 – Amateurs talk Strategy, Professionals talk Logistics

Ukraine Blog 64 – Barbarians

Iran Blog 01 - Why American Politics is Rotten to the Core